Here’s how the crossover SUV is killing the car industry…

Everyone in America during the 50s and 60s wanted a big car. Adverts bragged about how their car was wider and longer than the competition. They claimed these big cars fitted with highly inefficient V6s were safe, luxurious and a great statement of wealth. Being European, this concept used to seem odd, some would even consider it laughable. Isn’t it funny how times change?

It hasn’t been until recently that us Europeans have joined our friends across the pond by sharing that same desire for oversized cars. Even though our roads and car parks are still small, our desires have grown and popularity for bigger cars has been growing at an alarming rate for many years now.

Renault Crossover SUV (1)

For example, the SUV market share grew from 31% in 2017 (Jan-Apr) to 37% in 2018 (Jan-Apr). What’s even more impressive about this is that the car market as a whole saw a decline of 8.8%, meaning that even though fewer cars were sold in total compared to the previous period, SUV sales still managed to see an increase.

So, it’s clear that SUVs and crossovers are taking over the UK like a rash but why exactly is that a bad thing? Well, let us explain…

Crossovers are a step backwards in many ways so it’s very unfortunate that popular manufacturers such as Toyota, BMW and Audi are focussing so much of their resources on producing them.

Nissan Juke crossover (2)

Crossovers are meant to offer the best of both worlds, with the comfort and safety of an SUV paired with the economy and style of a hatchback or a saloon. However, in reality, a crossover has no real strengths as it is a jack-of-all-trades, master of none.

A crossover does not specialise in AWD technology for off-road driving, nor does focus on fuel efficiency, aerodynamics, speed, luxury or affordability. What are crossovers contributing to the auto industry, you ask? High seating positions and inflated prices, it seems.

They’re heavier and have poor aerodynamics, meaning that the engines must be more powerful and that fuel efficiency will be poorer. Crossovers, though they may look like 4×4 SUVs, are built upon car chassis and mostly lack AWD making them useless in the snow or off-road.

2019 Ford Puma Crossover (3)

Furthermore, despite them looking bigger, many crossovers are actually not that spacious inside. If you wanted a large boot, you would be better off buying an estate and enjoy the benefit of a lower load height. The interior space for passengers isn’t usually great either, with hatchbacks such as the Ford Focus, Toyota Auris and Honda Civic having more space than most crossovers.

The advantages of owning one of these compact SUVs is really just boiled down to having superior ride height. Many would argue that the crossover is just one big compromise and is the pioneer of nothing and ultimately, they contribute nothing to the advances of the car industry.

Toyota crossover (4)

The crossover is not just higher than other non-SUV cars, but they are also wider. Wider, taller and sometimes longer, these cars are also not the best for urban driving. Tight turns, narrow roads and small parking spaces are all things that make owning one of these pompous machines a bit of a nightmare. Unfortunately, this nightmare is shared with every other driver that wishes to park their car in said car parks as we may find that space is no longer adequate thanks to the ginormous Toyota RAV4 parked next to it.

Most of the time, an oversized car comes with an oversized ego. Another one of the main selling points of a crossover SUV is that they look “flashy”. Just like in 1960’s America, the bigger the car, the better. Research carried out by OSV Ltd. found that 35% of participants would purchase or have purchased an SUV for the status symbol.

Citeron DS crossover (5)

So, we know that SUVs are often bought for the status symbol and we also know that these cars have a rather high ride height. Put the two together and you could have an entitled driver on your hands who thinks they own the road. Interestingly, the same study also found that 54% of participants voted SUV drivers as the most annoying drivers on the road!

Crossovers are great to look at and maybe fun to drive but their influence on the car industry doesn’t appear to be very positive. It would be interesting to find out if our readers agree with us on this topic, so be sure to let us hear your thoughts in the comments!

Like What You’ve Read?

For more articles like this, receive our weekly e-newsletter, including partner deals and all things motoring, register your email below.

Please note: You cannot subscribe to Motor-Vision unless you put a tick in the checkbox below to indicate have read and agreed to our privacy policy.

2 Responses

  1. Richard Piper

    I totally agree the market has gone bonkers. SUV’s and Crossovers have their place but manufacturers are going silly finding ever more niche segments for these vehicles. I am just amazed at the taste and sense of those buying BMW X4’s and X6’s. IMHO MPV’s like the Ford B Max and C Max or even plain Estate cars are a far better proposition but they are obviously not deemed sexy enough. It also worries me in their quest to fund the development of more Crossover’s and SUV’s manufacturers are cutting back not just on mainstream saloons but particularly coupe’s and convertible’s. Also with automatic transmissions become standard on so many models they seems to be a diminishing range of cars for the enthusiast driver and petrolhead.

  2. Edward Harding

    I have a Volvo XC70 which is not a crossover it is a four wheel drive version of the V70 which has been one of the best estate cars ever for a long time. Often referred to as the antique dealers car. It, like its 3 predecessors, was purchased to tow a caravan. People who often buy Range Rovers, Land Cruisers etc but live in an estate house are the ones who are trying to make a statement. Why would one want a top drawer off roader when the only off road driving they do is parking on the pavement? Most of them are company cars and driven by the wife many of whom demonstrate that the vehicle is too big for them to easily control. And yes they are usually badly parked causing the bay next to them to be only suitable for a Fiat 500 or Smart car.

Leave a Reply